Tuesday, April 25, 2017

BYOD - Deb Tison

Bring Your Own Device - many elementary schools in Poway Unified School District have launched one  BYOD Day each week when students can bring in a device to work on in their school classroom.  The classroom teacher uses that day to introduce an app or two that is useful for a project the students are working on.  BYOD Days accomplished a few things:
1. increase integrated technology use with no capital investment by school district
2. increase time for teachers to find and master age-appropriate apps
3. increase time for technical support staff to upgrade wi-fi, band-width and other necessary technical support
Despite the gradual nature of one or two BYOD Days at a school or in a class, the hurdles are numerous.  In an article from teachhub.com entitled "The Disadvantage of iPads in the Classroom" the author points out several disadvantages which would affect any device including Wi-Fi issues, charging issues, and "too many options" in addition to several others.  In addition, the variety of devices can present additional technical hurdles that the classroom teacher is now expected to resolve in the midst of teaching a class of students.  Despite the challenges, the gradual roll-out of integrated technology is more effective and possibly more efficient than a sudden switch to being a "1:1 School".

Schools that have instantaneously become "1:1" schools have encountered many pitfalls  mentioned above in addition to insufficient bye-in from teachers, lack of technical support, insufficient professional development, and lack of community support.   A 1:1 school is committed to each student having their own device(either a tablet or laptop depending on age) and the expectation is that the primary mode of teaching be computer-based.  Many of the trials and tribulations of this transition are detailed in the 2008 report on the effectiveness of the legislated "technology immersion" program in Texas: "Evaluation of the Texas Technology Immersion Program 2004-2008".  Despite the legislative mandate, the process of introducing, teaching and supporting technology at schools throughout Texas was riddled with issues that hindering its efficacy.  An example was that despite the goal being "technology immersion", many of the evaluated schools were averaging only one or two days per week of computer-based instruction.

Although the goals are similar, BYOD Days and "Technology Immersion" are two drastically different paths to increasing integrated technology use in the classroom.  Each educational community must choose wisely which path to embark upon.

Works Cited

For Educational Research, Texas Center. "Evaluation of the Texas Technology Immersion Pilot." ERIC. Texas Center for Educational Research, Jan. 2008. Web. 24 Apr. 2017.
http:www.teachhub.com/advantagesdisadvantages-ipad-classroomTheDisadvantages of iPads in the Classroom


Monday, April 24, 2017

BYOD (Bring Your Own Device)

With the increase in people having smart phones or tablets, many library users now bring their own devices rather than use the computers available to them.  There is still a major need for these computers though since there are still users who cannot financially afford these devices.  With users bringing their own devices in, new issues can arise such as how to protect users privacy.



In a school library, the increase in students having their own devices changes how the library is being used.  BYOD “potentially diminishes the use of a classroom library as students learn that they can explore, investigate, and collaborate globally, with the library as the focal point for information use and sharing” (Marcoux, pg. 65).  Basically, the school library is sometimes being used more as a meeting area then necessarily for borrowing books.  As stated by Nelson, “We have the exciting opportunity to tech students to ask the right questions, use the real-world tools that they have in their hands to find the best answers, and share that in an authentic way with those around them” (2012, pg. 15).  The great thing is now school librarians can support students with how to best use their own devices to find accurate information quickly.

Works Cited

 Marcoux, Elizebeth. (2014, February). “BYOD”. Teacher Librarian., v41 n3. pg65.  Retrieved from http://web.a.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.palomar.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=fca5d1ed-1366-403a-bcfa-42d0717983df%40sessionmgr4008&vid=2&hid=4112.

The Demise Of School Libraries

School libraries are as important today as they were decades ago.  Although just as public libraries have changed to become community anchors that are not just a storage space for books, school libraries have been changing to include additional duties.  Much of their tasks now include maintaining a web page.  For example, below is a book trailer for “Twilight” that Twin Peaks Middle School Library has on their webpage, you can view it directly on their virtual library web page, https://sites.google.com/a/powayusd.com/tpms-virtual-library/. 

                                           https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4zsyCJQOPC4&feature=youtu.be


As discussed by Wernick, school libraries are shifting due to two reasons “the slow demise of the traditionally published book as the primary source of information; and the increasing demand for more collaborative, social environments for academic study and production” (2011, p. 25-26).  It is also incredibly important for librarians to help guide students to accurate information.  With so much information on the Internet that may or may not be factually accurate, students need support to know how to weed out misinformation.  So, I would definitely say that school libraries are not disappearing but rather evolving due to the new needs of the students and teachers they serve.


Works Cited


Wernick, Laura. (2011, May). “The School Library Space is Changing”. American School & University, v83 n9. 24-28.  Retrieved from http://palomar.worldcat.org.ezproxy.palomar.edu/title/the-school-library-space-is-changing/oclc/757386042.  

Cloud Computing in Libraries

What is cloud computing and is it beneficial to libraries? Let us begin with the definition. According to Wikipedia: “Cloud computing is a type of Internet-based computing that provides shared computer processing resources and data to computers and other devices on demand. It is a model for enabling ubiquitous, on-demand access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources (e.g., computer networks, servers, storage, applications and services),which can be rapidly provisioned and released with minimal management effort.” Here is the link to the page Wikipedia. Charles Leadbeater points out in his article Cloud Culture: the Promise and the Threat “there is a helpful analogy in the phrase cloud computing”. “Real clouds are Creative Commons share-alike licenseall made from the same fundamental component (i.e. water droplets), and these atmospheric clouds morph continuously from one type (e.g. cirrus) to another (e.g. stratus or cumulus). Similarly, shared online computing resources are the fundamental common component most modern networked applications and communities run on the same basic mix of IT infrastructure. The flexibility and scalability of cloud computing means that virtual clouds can form and dissipate as often as real clouds, depending on the interests and demands of end users.”




According to The Digital Shift there are pros and cons to libraries using cloud computing. They list these in their article The Library Cloud Pros and Cons . For the most part, I agree with this article. The greatest con, in my opinion, is security, which was my first thought when I heard about cloud computing for libraries. We, as library support staff, have access to lots of personal information which, if leaked to the general public, could harm our patrons. Also, there is the Privacy Act, which protects the people’s information from being given to anyone without their written consent. The person who would make the decision of what company to go with, will need to do their research and remember the old saying “you get what you pay for”. Free or cheap definitely is not always better.
That said, there are more pros than cons with using cloud computing in a library. One pro is the flexibility. When the library needs more computing resources, it is there, without adding expensive servers. Since there is never enough funding for libraries, this is a huge factor. Another positive outcome of cloud computing would be the technical support provided by the vendor. If library staff do not have a lot of technical expertise, that is okay. This is one of the things you are paying for.
Overall, I think cloud computing is a great idea. It is just very important to remember to do your research before you choose a company. Take your time and read as much as possible online. Also, check with other libraries who have made the switch. Word of mouth is usually the best source of information.

Leadbeater, Charles. "CLOUD CULTURE: THE PROMISE AND THE THREAT." Edge. John Brockman, 7 May 2011. Web. 22 Apr. 2017.


Corrado, Edward M., and Heather Lea Moulaison. "The Library Cloud Pros and Cons." The Digital Shift. School Library Journal, 5 Mar. 2012. Web. 22 Apr. 2017.

Sunday, April 23, 2017

BYOB

Bring your own electronic device to school or a library program is a new concept to me. I am not sure how I feel about it. There are both pros and cons to this idea. As a parent, I can see the problems which could arise in schools. As library support staff, I can see the advantages of people bringing their own devices.
For school, the parent would need to buy the device. This could be a problem for the students from lower income families. Some families are struggling to put food on the table. To ask them to come up with enough money to buy an electronic device could cause a great financial hardship. If they do manage to buy their child an electronic device, it might be a cheaper one, which could possibly lead to bullying. It can also lead to parents needing to choose between a device and another necessity for school (such as wi-fi). As one parent stated in the study Bring Your Own Device to Secondary School: The Perceptions of Teachers, Students and Parents, “The homework set was assuming that everyone had broadband which we didn't because I couldn't afford it as I was paying off a tablet (we now have it).” You can access this study at http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1099110.pdf . The study is full of great information collected from teachers, students, and parents who participated in a pilot program of students bringing their own devices to school for classwork purposes and using these same devices for homework.
Another thing parents complained about was their child spending too much time with the device and not enough time with their family. As our children become teens, they spend little enough time with us as it is. As a parent, I would not like my child to spend even more time in their room.
For programming in a library, I can definitely see the ways patrons could benefit from this idea. We could provide more patrons with training, rather than just the few based on how many devices the library owns. When there are technology based programs, registration fills up quickly because there are not enough computers, laptops, etc. for all the people wanting to attend. At my library  we only have 16 computers in our computer lab and no handheld devices. With this type of program, we could use the money that would be spent on expensive devices to purchase other things. We could offer resume and job search assistance to many more people than just the 16 our computer lab can hold.
This is an example of how libraries can offer more programming to customers if they bring their own device.
Another benefit  of BYOD is children could learn coding and not be confined to a computer desk and a limit of just a few seats. We could also provide teen friendly programming in a more relaxed environment if they brought their own device as well as focus the program on what we are trying to teach rather than how to use a device the customer has not used before.
As with any new idea, there are bumps in the road. As we test them out, we find ways to make the idea or program better. I am sure a couple of months from now there will be new data and more information on ways to successfully have people BYOB.





Walton, Graham. "Will Smart Phones and Other Bring Your Own Devices (BYOD) Dominate How Academic Library Services Are Developed and Delivered for the Foreseeable Future?." New Review of Academic Librarianship, vol. 20, no. 1, Jan-Apr2014, pp. 1-3. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1080/13614533.2014.875294.





Parsons, David and Janak Adhikar. "Bring Your Own Device to Secondary School: The Perceptions of Teachers, Students and Parents." Electronic Journal of E-Learning, vol. 14, no. 1, 01 Jan. 2016, pp. 66-80. EBSCOhost, ezproxy.palomar.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eric&AN=EJ1099110&site=ehost-live&scope=site.

Makerspaces

Makerspace.com defines a makerspace as: "A makerspace is a collaborative work space inside a school, library, or separate public/private facility for making, learning, exploring, and sharing that uses high tech to no tech tools"
https://www.makerspaces.com/what-is-a-makerspace/



Makerspaces seem to be a place where you can be yourself and at the same time be challenged as you think outside of the box. Makerspaces can be especially valuable to children. When children are in a makerspace, they are experimenting, collaborating, problem solving, gaining self-confidence, and becoming lifelong learners. Anything we can do to boost a child's self-esteem and confidence, is a good thing. The items used can be as simple as craft materials or elaborate as 3D printers,welding equipment, and laser cutters.





I am amazed by some of the things people have created in a makerspace. The time, patience, and ingenuity that goes into these projects is impressive. People have made things as elaborate as a robot! you can also use makerspaces to create things that look simple but are really ingenuitive, like a battery out of pennies, or electronic greeting cards.
Makerspaces.com has many wonderful ideas with lots of pictures. https://www.makerspaces.com/makerspace-ideas/ If you are looking for more ideas of things to create, check out Youtube:.There are many videos demonstrating how to create your own makerspace as well as videos of things people have made.
Science was my least favorite subject in school, but if we’d had makerspaces this might not have been so. The opportunity to learn while creating and collaborating with my classmates would have likely changed that. I am sure it would help a lot of students who are struggling with science. These are the kids who think science is boring, just like I used to.
Makerspaces could also help students struggling with math. I saw in a video some people using blocks in a makerspace to teach fractions in math. This would help students understand fractions and show them how it can be applied to real life.
Makerspaces are the future. I am happy to watch it grow and develop. Hopefully someday soon there will be makerspaces in all schools and public libraries. They don’t have to be expensive and there is always grant funding to help with the costs. I feel the difference they make is worth the money spent.
There are so many websites out there that can help you when you are ready to create your own makerspace. As my 10 year old daughter says “If you want to learn about something, just Google it”!


Links:

The Demise of School Libraries

The demise of school libraries is extremely heartbreaking to me. As a child who grew up in a low income family, the library was very important to me. I loved to read. From the time I learned to read, most of my free time was spent reading a book. For the early part of my elementary school years, I used the school library and the public library. My family moved right before I started 3 grade, to a small town with no public library. I would have died if it wasn’t for my school library (inside anyway). My school library seemed so large to me then. I realize now, it wasn’t. But it still had my favorites, Nancy Drew, Trixie Belden, and Judy Blume, to name a few. The library always felt so welcoming to me and smelled wonderful.
There are many reasons why we need school libraries. One is how not having one affects students. Here is a link to school library impact studies There are links to studies conducted all over the US, showing the impact of having a school library with School Library Staff. Now, more than ever, school libraries are important. Not just for their physical collection of books, but for the support the staff provide to teachers, students, and parents. With students using the internet more and more, they need someone to direct them to accurate information. Especially now, with so much false news out there. School library staff also support teachers by having resources available for the students on the subjects they are teaching. Not just books, but websites as well. There are school libraries that have time set aside each day where parents can come to the library and read with their child. Studies have shown that parents who read with their child are more likely to have children who enjoy reading. The following link lists many reasons why it is important for parents to read with their child.
It isn’t just about loving to read but so much more. There are many parents who cannot afford to buy books, and live in areas where they do not have access to public libraries. Where will these much needed books come from if not for the school library?
There have been many studies showing the importance of having school library staff in a school library. Students with staff who work only in the library increases test scores. Not just reading scores, but writing scores as well. With most of our communication done through writing now, email, text messages, social media posts, etc., these skills are extremely important. Take a look at this chart created by the Pennsylvania School Library Association.



They partnered with the Education Law Center, a nonprofit educational advocacy organization that has made substantial gains for the state's most vulnerable children - including poor kids, kids of color, kids with disabilities, English-language learners, and others. They persuaded the state's House of Representatives to commission the Pennsylvania School Library Study of 2011 - a "snapshot" of library programs in which 73 percent of public schools participated. This chart shows what they discovered. As you can see, students with Certified Library Staff scored higher on their tests, than students without this second person.
I feel very passionate about the importance of school libraries. Hopefully, research like the one conducted by the Pennsylvania School Librarians Association will help prove this to the people who make who make the decisions regarding funding to our school libraries. We also need parents to speak up. Librarians and Library Support Staff can advocate for school libraries as well. For the future of our students, our country, we need school libraries.




Lance, Keith Curry, and Bill Schwarz. How Pennsylvania School Libraries Pay Off: Investments in Student Achievement and Academic Standards. PA School Library Project. HSLC, Oct. 2012. Web. 1 June 2013.