There is no doubt that libraries must to keep innovated because "the BYOD (Bring your own device world is not only now, it is also tomorrow" (Marcoux, Teacher Librarian). Some of the benefits of BYOD are "the increase of student access to school provided ebooks, etextbooks and moodle units" (Jonson, Head for the Edge) In addition, it helps expand the learning allowing users to do research beyond the library setting. It is also important to mention that from this great advantage there also comes disadvantages such as privacy concerns and the fact that students with low income will be left behind because of the lack these resources.
Marcoux, Elizabeth. "BYOD."Teacher Librarian(2014): 41(3)-65.EBSCOhost. Web. 24 Mar. 2017.
Johnson, Doug. "Head for the Edge."Library Media ConnectionAug. 2012: 98.Ezproxy. Web. 26 Apr. 2017.
BOYD, or Bring Your Own Device, time in schools has been gaining momentum in recent years. BOYD allows students to use their own devices to work on projects and collaborate in groups. Teachers can use this constructively to show the students a new educational app or how to improve a presentation or video.
An advantage of BOYD is that schools can save a huge amount of money by not equipping expensive computer labs. Another is that students can easily access their projects at school or at home without having to email, download, and convert files, some of which may not be compatible with their devices at home or at school.
A potential downside is considering the students who are low-income and do not have devices of their own who may feel left out as all of their peers take out their own devices and begin working. “Schools need to be sensitive to the needs, and ability to afford technology tools, of all families that they serve,” says Peter Vogel, a physics teacher. Another potential problem is that many young people today already spend too much time in front of a screen. Teachers may also have a more difficult time making sure students are staying on task when they are on mobile devices. However, if students believe that they are learning about useful technology that is directly related to future jobs, they are likely to be interested and motivated in the lesson instead of just reading another chapter in another textbook.
“These devices are so influential in our students’ lives. It is part of the way they’re being raised,” says Aubrey Dawe, an elementary school principal. Peter Vogel points out “[BYOD] can save a school money on infrastructure and may foretell the end of dedicated classroom computer labs. However, BYOD typically means a major revamping of a school’s Internet delivery technology, specifically advanced wireless capabilities.”
BOYD allows teachers to incorporate technology lessons in their teaching without having to schedule trips to schools library computer labs. They could opt to stay in their regular classroom and have a short time to use educational software or creative projects. This could save space in the computer lab for classes needing good desktop computers to download large files, such as working on large videos, or a large screen to work on graphic-intensive projects. BOYD device is also a way for schools to demonstrate that learning environments can be innovative and focused on the future instead of stuffy and useless, and to demonstrate that the internet and technology can be extremely powerful tools when used appropriately.
As schools face budget shortfalls and teacher layoffs, and as society transitions more and more to electronic instead of print resources, funding to school libraries is cut and they are seen as expendable. More and more, school librarian positions are reduced to part-time jobs.
The most important point to consider is what is the purpose of a school library and why would schools still need them. What do school libraries offer that public libraries do not?
First, many children may not be able to get to the city library on a regular basis if it is located on the other side where they live and their parents have busy schedules. They may not have easy access on a weekly basis to books and other materials. Having a library that children can go to as a class and browse books and a place they can conveniently return books before or after school will encourage children to check out more books and read.
Secondly, not all children have access to a computer at home, or if they do, they may not have access to a quiet, productive place to do their work. Librarians can be a valuable resource to help students learn how to use new programs and evaluate the legitimacy of websites.
Thirdly, just because students have the internet, ebooks, and other resources does not man they know how to navigate them to find information properly. The California Department of Education collected data that shows that the ratio of certified librarians to students in California is the lowest in the nation and that this translate into decreased access to books and reduced research skills in students according to the President of the California School Library Association, Janet Gilmore-See (EdSource, 2014). Teachers alone will not be able to provide the best education possible to students. They should have the help of highly qualified school support staff. Debra Kachel, in the New Republic, writes that research has found that students who attend schools with librarians perform better on reading and writing tests, and that this is especially true of students from low-income backgrounds.
There is no escape from the fact that how people obtain information and entertainment is changing, but this does not make library services obsolete or that librarie are not an integral part of helping students access and navigate new forms of information.
“Google answers in
one afternoon more reference questions than all the public libraries in the United States in
an entire year,” Helping patrons with reference inquiries “is not our business
anymore” says Bill Ptacek director of the King County Public Library System in
Washington state.
Barbara Mantel asserts, “as a result, many librarians are
being redeployed into the community, training daycare providers and parents in
early literacy skills and working in public schools".
Mantel
observes that “academiclibrarieshave seen a drastic decline in
reference requests but an increased demand for people space, whether to plug in
a laptop, quietly study or work on group projects, a reflection of teaching
trends that stress group assignments”.
“You
can say that space can happen anywhere on campus, and yes it can,” says Charles
Lowry of the Association of Research Libraries, “but it can't happen anywhere
else with a full array of information resources from print to electronic, with
expert help available from librarians and staff and in a central location. I
cannot imagine that you won't see physicallibrarieson
our campuses 10 years and probably 25 years from now.”
Mantel wonders, “should the physical library shrink as
books, journals and other materials increasingly become available in digital
form? What role will libraries play if e-books come to dominate the reading
experience? And should public libraries be privatized in an effort to save money?”
Mantel, B. (2011, July 29). Future of
libraries.CQ
Researcher,21, 625-652.
We’ve all heard
of the Cloud by now, but understanding what it actually is can be confusing. In
her article “Libraries in the Cloud: Making a Case for Google and Amazon,” Stephanie
Buck defines cloud computing as “the availability of IT-type needs offered as
services, often through a third-party vendor” (2009, 6). While the cloud
provides different types of services, the two services most beneficial to
libraries are data storage and software as a service. Putting the burdens of
server maintenance and software updates on an outside vendor clears up workflow
time (and often extra funds) for libraries to enjoy. Many smaller libraries
could even get away with using free services like Google Apps for their
in-house data management and save even more money (2009, 10).
Libraries with deep
digital collections could benefit greatly from using cloud-based data storage. Doing
so would ease the library’s bandwidth and allow patrons to access the
collections even faster. “…with faster retrieval times for patron requests and
more local server space, it could improve storage solutions for libraries”
(2009, 10).
As more and
more digital content is created every minute, having adequate server storage space
is critical. Libraries need to make sure they keep up with everyone else and
utilize this important technology. Changing like this will affect many
libraries and their staff in different ways, but the transformation is necessary
and will lead to a more advanced future for data access and retrieval.
Resources
Buck, Stephanie. "Libraries in the Cloud: Making a
Case for Google and Amazon." Computers in Libraries, vol. 29, no.
8, Sept. 2009, pp. 6-10. EBSCOhost,
ezproxy.palomar.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=aph&AN=44301305&site=ehost-live&scope=site.
As school
libraries adapt to students’ changing needs and add collaborative spaces and
surfaces to their layouts, many of these spaces are becoming something special.
Makerspaces are areas in libraries devoted to facilitating group activities
such as arts and crafts, electronics, LEGO, sewing, and anything else requested
by patrons and provided by staff. In her article “Help! My Principal Says I
Need to Start a Makerspace in My Elementary Library!” Kristin Fontichiaro gives
expert advice on how to start a makerspace on a budget. “In a classroom, [a
makerspace] could be the addition of science kits to the curriculum, plus a few
bookshelves of tinkering kits and materials to keep kids engaged during down time.
In a public library, it might be the addition of new programming…or a set of
circulating science or art equipment. In a school library, it might range from
centers designed for mental relaxation to…digital fabrication tools like a 3D
printer” (2016, 49). I visited the makerspace in the Carlsbad City Library,
which is essentially a computer lab with two 3D printers. Staff give presentations
teaching how to 3D print, and patrons can sign up for appointments for longer
printing jobs.
Here is a video
showing a makerspace created by the Stewart Library:
Because of the
modular, snowflake nature of makerspaces, Kristin recommends communicating with
the administration to understand their goals for adopting one. Once staff is all
on the same page about the purpose for the makerspace (relaxation versus
creation versus exploration, etc.), they should research what the students want
or need in such a space. Based on the purpose and the students’ input, staff
can plan to acquire the right elements for the makerspace. Be also mindful of
budgeting for the present and future of the makerspace. Discuss with the administration
about what to buy and when. “Be sure to work with your principal on
differentiating between start-up costs (for once-only purchases like a sewing
machine or Silhouette paper cutter) and long-term costs (for occasional
purchases like cardboard, fabric, equipment repair, or 3D filament)” (2016, 49).
For a
makerspace to be healthy and bustling, Kristin recommends selecting a variety
of categories for activities and advertising them brightly so students or
patrons will flock to the activities that inspire them. Once its presence is
known, all staff have to do is maintain the budget and the scheduling of
activities and the makerspace will thrive.
Resources
Fontichiaro, Kristin. "Help! My Principal Says I
Need to Start a Makerspace in My Elementary Library!." Teacher
Librarian, vol. 44, no. 1, Oct. 2016, pp. 49-51. EBSCOhost,
ezproxy.palomar.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=aph&AN=119117883&site=ehost-live&scope=site.
As information technology
evolves with the needs of the users, the library space itself is changing too. I
didn’t get to see much of it firsthand, myself: I matriculated from middle
school to high school in the year 2000, which was an awkward time to be a
student. The libraries at the elementary and middle schools I attended had been
traditionally low-tech, with rows of wonderful old books and a barely used
television set. As soon as I left them behind and went to high school, they
started getting improvements like iMac computers and brand new books. My high
school library had a modest, early computer lab, a small room with ten or so
basic computers. In my years at that school it was mainly used to teach typing
classes. I remember being assigned only a very simple research exercise and I hadn’t
learned much of anything about information literacy.
I’ve not
returned to my high school since I graduated in 2004, so I can only guess as to
any improvements the library’s gained since then. It doesn’t have its own
website that I can find, but the high school directory lists two librarians. I hope
that they’ve at least addressed some of the changes mentioned by Laura Wernick
in her article “The School Library Space Is Changing.” Due to the rise of
digital information formats, and the shift to adopt a more relaxed, social atmosphere
for students to employ in individual- to group-sized projects, many school
libraries across the country have redesigned their layouts to “include
centralized access to specialists who can explain resource research and
retrieval in a technologically complex world [and] complete integration of
technology throughout the space, enabling students to work together for
research and production…” (2011, 26). The following video shows an
excellent example of such upgrades being employed at Turner Valley School in
2015:
Although funding is always a problem
for libraries, they are suffering less of a demise and more of a metamorphosis.
I hope my old high school library replaced its uncomfortable tables and chairs—and
its stuffy little computer room—with a brighter, comfier space with sofas and media
interfaces spread throughout the bookshelves. I hope the staff are readily
available to all the students and teach them more thoroughly about trustworthy
sources of information and how to find it. And I hope more classes allot
library time more often to engage in collaborative activities and to access
education digitally more easily than in the classroom.
Resources
Wernick, Laura. "The School Library Space Is
Changing." American School & University, vol. 83, no. 9, 01 May
2011, pp. 24-28. EBSCOhost,
ezproxy.palomar.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eric&AN=EJ935431&site=ehost-live&scope=site.